SHORT STORY 3
Today I went to visit the man without a memory. The ward was constructed as you'd expect. Drab. Gray. The platonic ideal of depressive, repressive architecture. Its most interesting feature was a uniform cantilever halfway up, as if it had been constructed on a tiny parcel and only by invading others' airspace could it accommodate the internal empire.
The man without a memory was too, how you would expect. How it happened is unknown, but one imagines a construction accident. Pipe through the skull, coring out a portion of the hippocampus, a researcher taking the arctic's memories with him with a bore. Or perhaps it was a brain-eating bacteria. Or maybe the sin was more original, a genetic malformation that triggered at some inopportune moment.
Regardless, he was always rather lucid in the moment. I went up the elevator. He was on the first floor-the other floors serving some other public purpose-but the elevator accelerated as if it was going to the tenth floor all the same, blood rushing to my head and then back down to my feet. Red out.
Inside the ward was slightly more inviting. More than you'd expect, anyway. Mildly midcentury, warm lighting, carpet shifted from vermillion to burgundy with age. Somewhat of an American caricature, like an old diner or a hotel lobby from a film about the fifties that was itself made in the seventies.
He was sitting by the window when I arrived. Same chair as always, though he wouldn't know that. The attendant nodded me in and left us alone.
"Hello," I said.
He turned. His face cycled through calibrations: surprise, alarm, something approaching joy. "First visitor in twenty years."
I'd heard this before. "How do you know?"
"Mirror." He touched his jaw. "Erosion. I remember being young. Now I'm not."
"Your name?"
"Of course." Slight smile. "I'm not stupid. Just very specifically broken."
I sat. "You can still speak."
"Language is spinal. Piano hands. You forget practice but the fingers move." He flexed them. "I mean-I don't forget practice. I never remember it. Different thing."
We sat in silence for a moment. Out the window, the city sprawled in its typical industrial indifference.
"I need to tell you something," I said. "About my daughter."
He turned to me with complete attention. A blank page.
"Amanda's twenty-six now. Works in graphic design-or she did, last I heard directly from her, which was three months ago. We used to talk every Sunday. Like clockwork. I'd call her after breakfast, she'd tell me about her week, her projects, whatever guy she was seeing at the time. Mostly I'd listen. That was the agreement we'd settled into, though neither of us ever said it explicitly. I'd listen, I'd offer advice when asked, I'd tell her I loved her before we hung up.
"Then last November she asked if we could add her mother to Thanksgiving. Just the three of us. She said it casually, like she was asking to bring a bottle of wine. I was quiet for a long time. You know that kind of quiet where you can hear the other person breathing on the line, where the silence itself becomes a kind of statement? Finally I said, 'I don't think that's a good idea.'
"She asked why not. I told her that her mother had made certain choices, that forgiveness wasn't the same as reconciliation, that some doors close and should stay closed. That Thanksgiving was our tradition, mine and hers, and had been for fifteen years, and bringing her mother into it would change what it meant. I said it would be dishonest.
"Amanda got very quiet too. Then she said, 'Dad, she was sick.' I said I knew that. Depression, I said, is a real illness, I'm not disputing that. But being sick doesn't absolve you of the consequences of your actions. If an alcoholic crashes their car, we can acknowledge the disease and still recognize the damage.
"'She didn't crash a car,' Amanda said. 'She got depressed and you left her.'
"'She left us,' I said. 'Emotionally. Checked out completely. Do you remember those months? I'd come home and she'd be in bed. You'd be sitting on the floor in front of the TV eating cereal for dinner because she couldn't be bothered to get up. A mother's first responsibility is to her child. She failed that responsibility.'
"Amanda was crying by then. I could hear it in her breathing. She said, 'You're talking about her like she's a stranger. Like she didn't raise me for twelve years before that happened.'
"'Thirteen years,' I corrected her. 'And I'm talking about her like someone who understands that love is a verb, not just a feeling. You can feel all the love in the world, but if you can't get out of bed to feed your daughter, what does it matter?'
"She hung up on me. Didn't call the next Sunday. Or the one after that. Three months now. I've left messages. Texts. Nothing aggressive, nothing angry. Just checking in. She's read them-you can see that now, the little read receipts-but she doesn't respond."
I stopped. The man without a memory was looking at me with intense focus.
"That's very painful," he said.
"Yes."
"Were you right? About Thanksgiving?"
"I was honest."
He looked at his hands. Turned them over. "Being honest."
"Yes."
"What did your daughter do for Thanksgiving?"
"I don't know. I spent it alone."
He nodded. We watched the light change outside. A plane passed, silent through the glass.
"Actually," I said, "that's not quite how it happened. The Thanksgiving thing was there, but what really ended it was the money. This was in January. Amanda called-she'd been distant since November but was still talking to me-and she said her mother was in trouble. Behind on rent, about to be evicted. Asked if I could lend her five thousand dollars.
"I laughed. Not a cruel laugh, just-automatic. Surprised. 'You're asking me to give money to your mother?' I said. 'The same woman who spent a year and a half barely able to work, who I supported through all of that, who then decided she needed to "find herself" and left?'
"'Dad,' Amanda said, 'she's going to be homeless.'
"'She has a sister. She has friends. She has, presumably, some kind of job, even if she can't manage to keep up with rent. Why is this my problem?'
"'Because I'm asking you,' Amanda said. 'Because I'm your daughter and I'm asking you to help someone I love.'
"I got angry then. Really angry. I told her that I'd spent fifteen years building a life for the two of us, that I'd worked sixty-hour weeks at a job I hated to make sure she could go to college without debt, that I'd sacrificed my own relationship possibilities because I didn't want to confuse her with a parade of stepmother candidates. I'd earned my money. I'd earned my peace. And I wasn't going to subsidize the same woman who'd abandoned us.
"'She didn't abandon us,' Amanda said. 'You keep saying that but it's not true. She got sick and you couldn't handle it, so you left her. And then you spent fifteen years making sure I understood that was somehow her fault.'
"That's when I said it. The thing I regret. I said, 'If you can't see the difference between a sick person and a bad mother, then I've failed you more completely than she ever did.'
"She said, 'You haven't failed me, Dad. But you're not the person I thought you were.' And she hung up.
"I sent the money the next day. Five thousand dollars, directly to her mother's account. I thought it would fix things. Amanda sent it back. Included a note: 'She doesn't need it anymore. I gave her the money myself. I was asking because I wanted to know what kind of person you are. Now I know.'"
The man without a memory was still looking at me. Something different in his face now. More careful. Or less.
"You changed the story," he said.
"Same story. Different details."
"No." He shook his head once. "Different story."
I didn't answer. A nurse walked by in the hallway, shoes squeaking on linoleum. The sound seemed to catch his attention, then release it.
"The truth is," I said, "neither of those versions is quite right. Amanda's mother didn't leave us. I left her. After the depression got bad-after the first suicide attempt, the hospitalization, the weeks where she could barely speak-I couldn't take it anymore. Not because I didn't love her. I did. But I was terrified. Terrified that Amanda would come home from school one day and find her mother dead. Terrified that I'd wake up next to a corpse. Terrified that I'd say the wrong thing and it would be the thing that tipped her over.
"So I made a decision. I told her I was taking Amanda and moving out. Just temporarily, I said. Just until you get better. Just until things stabilize. I'd bring Amanda to visit every weekend. We'd do family dinners. But I needed to know Amanda was safe, and I couldn't trust that in that house, with her, anymore.
"She begged me not to. Said she needed us there. Said she was trying. But I'd already rented the apartment. I'd already enrolled Amanda in a new school, closer to my office. I'd already made up my mind.
"She did get better, eventually. Medication, therapy, electroconvulsive treatment finally. Took two years. By then Amanda and I had our routines. Our Sunday calls. Our Thanksgiving tradition. Her mother would try to insert herself back in-birthday cards, Christmas presents, invitations to coffee-and I never forbade Amanda from seeing her. I was very careful about that. Very correct. But I'd make observations. Little things. 'Your mother seems tired today, doesn't she? I hope she's taking care of herself.' Or, 'Did she remember to pick you up on time? Good, good. I just worry.' Or my favorite: 'I'm so glad you're stable, sweetheart. That you don't have her emotional... fragility.'
"I was planting seeds. Making sure Amanda understood that her mother was fundamentally unreliable. Damaged. And that I- I was the one who'd saved her from all that.
"When Amanda asked me for the money, she wasn't asking for rent. Her mother was trying to go back to school. Community college, nursing degree. She wanted to restart her life. Amanda wanted to help her. And I said no because I wanted her mother to fail. I wanted Amanda to watch her fail. I wanted vindication for every anxious night, every moment of terror, every sacrifice I'd made. I wanted Amanda to see that I'd been right all along to leave."
I stopped.
The man without a memory looked at me for a long time. Or what seemed like a long time. Hard to tell if he was thinking or if the thought had already passed through and out.
"Why are you telling me this?"
"Because you won't remember."
"No." He was very still. "But you will."
We sat there. The afternoon light slanted through the window, catching dust motes in its amber geometry.
"You keep changing it," he said finally. "Each time different."
"I'm trying to find-"
"The one that makes sense?" He looked at his hands again. Studied them like artifacts. "I do that too. Every morning I try to remember how I got here. Make up stories. Car accident one day. War injury the next. Fell off a building. Brain tumor. Stroke." He turned his hands over. "Doesn't matter which story I pick. I'm still here when I wake up."
He smiled, but it was distant. Already drifting.
"The story doesn't change it," he said. "What you did. What happened." He paused, and for a moment his eyes focused with surprising clarity. "You came here because I can't judge you. Can't hold it against you. Ten seconds and it's gone." Another pause. "But you'll still have said it. You'll remember saying it. To someone. That's what you needed."
I opened my mouth. Nothing came out.